Description
Review season runs from November through January and produces your most legally important employee records. A year-end review is often the first document an attorney requests in a discrimination or retaliation claim. A "meets expectations" rating followed by termination three months later becomes the employee's best evidence.
This webinar shows HR professionals how to run a review cycle that is honest, consistent, documented and free of bias. Learn to write comments about performance rather than personality, run calibration, handle high-risk reviews and build PIPs that either fix performance or support a fair exit.
Why now: ratings written over the next eight weeks will shape pay, promotion and discipline decisions for all of 2027.
Webinar Objectives
- Explain why year-end reviews are Exhibit A in discrimination and retaliation claims.
- Recognize and correct rating errors: leniency, recency, central tendency, halo and horns, and similarity bias.
- Write comments that are specific, behavior-based and tied to the job, and that match the year's documentation.
- Handle high-risk reviews after a complaint, protected leave or an accommodation request.
- Design a PIP with measurable goals, real support, a clear timeline and documented check-ins.
- Use AI tools in performance management without creating bias or notice violations.
Webinar Agenda
- Why reviews matter legally: the review as Exhibit A, the mismatch problem and adverse actions after Muldrow
- Preparing and calibrating: gathering the year's record, self-evaluations and consistent standards after Ames
- Writing the review: rating errors, language to avoid and SMART goals for 2027
- The review conversation: a simple structure, scripts for low ratings and a live role-play
- High-risk reviews and PIPs: complaint, leave and accommodation cases, and PIPs that hold up
Webinar Highlights
- 2026 Update: How the Muldrow and Ames Supreme Court decisions change the way reviews and PIPs are judged.
- 2026 Update: What Illinois (in effect since January 1, 2026) and California (since October 2025) now require for AI-drafted reviews and rating tools.
- The "set up to fail" PIP: warning signs that lead a court to see a PIP as cover for a decision already made.
- Calibration made practical: how to catch inflated or inconsistent ratings before they are delivered.
- Timely: delivered at the start of review season, so you can apply it to this year's cycle right away.
- Ready-to-use tools: review phrase bank, calibration checklist, PIP template and conversation script.
Who Should Attend?
- HR directors, managers and business partners
- HR generalists and employee relations specialists
- Talent, performance and compensation professionals
- Managers and supervisors who write and deliver reviews, including first-time managers
- Executives who approve ratings and pay decisions
- Small-business owners and solo HR professionals